Jacob Haller (jwgh) wrote,
Jacob Haller
jwgh

  • Music:

Anthology Deathmatch

This idea is stolen with permission from secritcrush.

I've got a bunch of anthologies sitting on the bookshelf that I haven't read in years, so perhaps it's time to read them again. It's time for an anthology smackdown!

As with secritcrush's, there will be three rounds where two anthologies go head to head, and then I'll pick the overall winner.

To make things sporting, I'm leaving out The Hugo Awards Volumes I & II (edited by Isaac Asimov), because that won secritcrush's Anthology Thunderdome and would almost certainly win mine. So here is a poll! Do not let not lack of knowledge of the books keep you from voting in it.

Poll #924556 Do you know what I'll like?

Defunct Magazine Smackdown

Galaxy: The Best of My Years edited by James Baen
7(43.8%)
The Best of Crank! edited by Bryan Cholfin
9(56.2%)

Sargent Battles Herself

Women of Wonder: The Classic Years edited by Pamela Sargent
8(50.0%)
Women of Wonder: The Contemporary Years edited by Pamela Sargent
8(50.0%)

The Odd Couple

The Best Japanese Science Fiction Stories edited by John L. Apostoluo and Martin H. Greenberg
11(68.8%)
Fantasia Mathematica edited by Clifton Fadiman
5(31.2%)

Jake will like this the best:

Galaxy: The Best of My Years edited by James Baen
0(0.0%)
The Best of Crank! edited by Bryan Cholfin
2(14.3%)
Women of Wonder: The Classic Years edited by Pamela Sargent
2(14.3%)
Women of Wonder: The Contemporary Years edited by Pamela Sargent
0(0.0%)
The Best Japanese Science Fiction Stories edited by John L. Apostoluo and Martin H. Greenberg
3(21.4%)
Fantasia Mathematica edited by Clifton Fadiman
7(50.0%)

Who cares what Jake likes? This should clearly be the winner:

Galaxy: The Best of My Years edited by James Baen
2(12.5%)
The Best of Crank! edited by Bryan Cholfin
2(12.5%)
Women of Wonder: The Classic Years edited by Pamela Sargent
3(18.8%)
Women of Wonder: The Contemporary Years edited by Pamela Sargent
2(12.5%)
The Best Japanese Science Fiction Stories edited by John L. Apostoluo and Martin H. Greenberg
4(25.0%)
Fantasia Mathematica edited by Clifton Fadiman
3(18.8%)
Tags: anthology deathmatch, reading
Subscribe
  • Post a new comment

    Error

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 10 comments